3.8.07

zoēpolitics: The Nonsense of Logic

zoēpolitics: The Nonsense of Logic

this finding finding this
video +

quote within quoting: call it citationality



'Lewis Caroll's Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass are two of the most famous examples of what is often described (in somewhat confusing terms), as 'literary nonsense'. Hence the keen interest shown towards them by Gilles Deleuze in the opening chapters of The Logic of Sense, which play extensively with the sense/nonsense dyad. At the same time, Carroll's two most famous tales also interest him because they critique the notion of 'sense' itself, dislodging any pretension that it could somehow exist as a power-free knowledge of 'the depths', of 'nature', of 'the organic'. Indeed, as we quickly find out, Alice's primary discovery in the course of the adventure is, in essence, that she has no originary essence; she, who 'is Alice' also is 'not Alice' - identity is nothing more than inscription (or better yet, conscription). As Deleuze puts it, "it is not a question of the adventures of Alice, but of Alice's adventure: her climb to the surface, her disavowal of false depth and her discovery that everything happens at the border. This is why Carroll abandons the original title of the book: Alice's Adventures Underground". It is from this perspective that I would suggest Spike Lee's most outstanding film Bamboozled (2000) should be watched, especially since the 'alternatives' are either to read it as 1) positing an originary benign identity for African-Americans that could somehow exist prior to its inscription, or 2) to naturalize the predominant malignant inscription, as if it were the only possible one. That both Delacroix and his father overcome the limits of the subjectivity into which they have been delivered, as well as participate in the reproduction of some of its most damaging aspects (that is, as it has been formed under the order of whiteness), only make Alice's adventure that much more relevant in the face of a constantly changing order of racial formation; as Deleuze emphasizes, "the loss of Alice's proper identity and name is repeated through all her adventures".